eLearning standards and platforms
SCORM vs xAPI: which one you need, and where cmi5 fits
SCORM puts a course inside an LMS and reports whether the learner finished and what they scored. xAPI records almost any activity, anywhere, and sends it to a separate data store. cmi5 is a set of rules that lets an LMS launch xAPI content the way it launches SCORM. Which one you need depends on where the training runs and what you have to receive the data.
Updated
Facts checked on 21 November 2026
SCORM, xAPI and cmi5 side by side
| SCORM | xAPI | cmi5 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it records | Completion, pass or fail, score, time, a bookmark and question answers, for one course in one LMS | Any activity, written as statements of who did what: "Priya completed the fire drill" | xAPI statements, plus a fixed set that every course must send for launch, completion, pass and fail |
| Where the content must live | Inside the LMS, on the same domain | Anywhere: a website, a mobile app, a simulator, a device | Anywhere. The LMS holds only a small course structure file |
| What you need on the receiving end | An LMS | A learning record store (LRS), on its own or built into an LMS | An LMS that supports cmi5, which includes an LRS |
| Launch from an LMS | Defined | Not defined | Defined |
| Offline and mobile apps | No It needs a browser session connected to the LMS | Yes Statements can be sent when a connection returns | Yes Mobile apps can be launched, and offline use is possible |
| Authoring tool and LMS support | Close to universal for 1.2 | Common in authoring tools. The LRS is the part many teams lack | Narrower. Check both ends before you commit |
| Effort to get a first report | Upload a zip and assign it | Set up an LRS, agree which statements to send, build the reports | Close to SCORM for the administrator, once both ends support it |
| Status of the standard | Last edition March 2009 | An IEEE standard since 2023 | First production release June 2016 |
Two rows settle most choices: where the content has to live, and what you have on the receiving end. SCORM needs an LMS and nothing more, which is why it is the default. xAPI needs an LRS, plus someone to decide which statements to send and to build reports from them.
What the records look like
Priya, a field engineer, finishes a pump maintenance module and then does the job on site. SCORM gives the LMS one row: Priya, Pump maintenance, completed, 85%, 22 minutes. xAPI can add what happened outside the course, one statement at a time. Priya watched the seal replacement video in the mobile app. Priya replaced a seal on pump 14. Her supervisor signed off the job.
The second kind of record is only worth collecting if someone will read it. Before you choose xAPI, name the report you want and the person who will act on it. If the answer is "a completion report for the audit", SCORM already gives you that.
The fuller definitions are on their own pages: what SCORM is, what xAPI is and what cmi5 is.
Which should you choose
| Your situation | Choose |
|---|---|
| Courses assigned and reported in one corporate LMS | SCORM 1.2 |
| Courses sold or handed to customers whose LMS you have never seen | SCORM 1.2 |
| Reports must show "completed" and "passed" separately, or long courses keep losing the learner's place | SCORM 2004, 3rd or 4th edition. See SCORM 1.2 vs 2004 |
| Learning happens in a mobile app, in a simulator or on the job | xAPI, with an LRS |
| You want training data from several systems in one place for analysis | xAPI, with an LRS |
| Content must stay on your own servers while customers launch it from their LMS | cmi5 if both ends support it. If not, a SCORM package that points at the hosted course |
| A university platform has to open an external tool with one sign-on | LTI, covered below |
If the content is a slide deck or a PDF and all you need is a tracked copy, SCORM takes a few minutes: see how to convert PowerPoint to SCORM. If a package misbehaves after upload, SCORM not working lists the causes by symptom.
Where cmi5 fits
xAPI by itself says how to record an activity. It does not say how an LMS should launch a course, tell the course who the learner is, or decide what counts as complete. An LMS therefore cannot treat a bare xAPI package the way it treats a SCORM one.
cmi5 fills that gap. The cmi5 project describes it as a profile, meaning a set of extra rules, for using xAPI with content launched from an LMS. The rules cover launch, authentication, session management, reporting and course structure.
The work began inside AICC in 2010, restarted on top of xAPI in 2012, and moved to ADL when AICC dissolved in 2014. The first production release, named Quartz, came out in June 2016.
- Content can sit on any server. It does not have to be inside the LMS.
- No dependence on pop-up windows or frames.
- Mobile apps can be launched, and offline use is possible.
- The data is xAPI, so it can be taken out of the LMS in bulk.
- SCORM 2004 sequencing, such as prerequisites and remediation paths. cmi5 has one "move on" rule per unit.
- Breadth of support. Fewer LMSs and authoring tools handle it.
The second column is the reason cmi5 is still a minority choice. ADL's Project CATAPULT page records why the US Department of Defense had not been buying cmi5 content: few LMSs and authoring tools supported it, and there was no conformance test suite. CATAPULT was set up to build a test suite and a prototype player. Some authoring tools now list cmi5 among their output formats (iSpring Free is one), but confirm support with both vendors in writing before you plan around it.
AICC, LTI and H5P: what each one is
These turn up in the same searches, and each is a different kind of thing.
SCORM vs AICC
AICC is the oldest of the tracking standards. Its web protocol, HACP, dates from February 1998 and sends data to the LMS as ordinary HTTP form posts, where SCORM uses script calls between browser windows. That design lets the content sit on a different server from the LMS, which SCORM does not allow.
The AICC committee dissolved in 2014, so nothing new is coming. scorm.com still describes it as widely supported, with adoption likely second only to SCORM 1.2. Use AICC when a system you have to work with asks for it, and leave it alone for new work.
SCORM vs LTI
LTI connects tools. It does not package or track a course. 1EdTech, which maintains it, describes a standard for linking learning tools to an institution's learning environment without a separate login for each tool. The current version is LTI 1.3, built on OAuth 2 and JSON Web Tokens, and the LTI Advantage services add grade return, class lists and deep links.
You meet LTI mostly in schools and universities, where the learning platform opens a publisher's or a tool vendor's site from inside a course. Choose it when what you have is a hosted tool and there is no file to upload.
SCORM vs H5P
H5P is an authoring tool. It is free, open source software under the MIT licence for building interactive HTML5 content, such as quizzes and interactive video, in a browser. It has plugins for Moodle, WordPress and Drupal, and a paid hosted service, H5P.com, connects to other LMSs over LTI.
H5P content produces xAPI statements and hands them to the platform it runs in. It has no link to an LRS of its own. So "SCORM vs H5P" sets a file format against a tool, and the useful question is whether your platform runs H5P and what it does with the results.
Is SCORM still relevant?
Yes, going by the usage figures Rustici Software publishes from its own platform.
Published in February 2026. SCORM 1.2 had the majority.
SCORM 2004 4th edition, March 2009. Nothing has been released since.
IEEE 9274.1.1-2023.
Quartz, June 2016.
Rustici is open that its sample leans towards SCORM, since SCORM is in the product's name, and it reports that cmi5 and xAPI use is growing. Even allowing for that, the gap is wide.
What counts against SCORM is its age. ADL, the US defence programme that created SCORM, wrote in its Fall 2022 reference for defence buyers that SCORM is "a legacy collection of standards" and that xAPI and cmi5 are to be prioritised, while accepting SCORM-only LMSs for existing systems.
ADL itself has since been wound down. Its reference pages on GitHub carry a notice saying the initiative has been formally retired, with its repositories archived and still public. xAPI now sits with the IEEE.
Read together, those sources say SCORM is finished in the sense of complete. "Legacy" here means no new features are coming. Nothing in those documents suggests LMSs will stop playing it. For a course launched from an LMS, no other format is accepted in as many places.
Recourse exports SCORM 1.2, and only that
Recourse turns a screen recording into software training people can practise, and builds whole courses from documents, videos and recordings. On the Pro plan a course exports as SCORM 1.2. With live SCORM the package points at the hosted course, so an edit reaches every LMS copy without a new upload. There is no xAPI, SCORM 2004, cmi5, AICC or LTI output. That suits a team whose training is launched from an LMS and reported with what SCORM 1.2 carries. It does not suit a team whose reporting runs on xAPI statements in an LRS, or whose LMS rules depend on 2004 sequencing. The free SCORM converters are separate and output 1.2 and 2004, and the free SCORM viewer opens both.
Start freeQuestions people ask
What is the difference between SCORM and xAPI?
Is SCORM still relevant?
Is xAPI replacing SCORM?
What is the difference between SCORM, xAPI and cmi5?
Do I need an LRS for xAPI?
What is the difference between SCORM and AICC?
Is LTI the same as SCORM?
Is H5P an alternative to SCORM?
Sources
- xapi.com (Rustici Software): comparison of SCORM, xAPI and cmi5
- xapi.com: xAPI overview
- cmi5 project: overview and history
- cmi5 project: SCORM and cmi5 compared
- ADL: about Project CATAPULT
- ADL: DoDI 1322.26 reference pages on GitHub
- ADL: DoDI 1322.26 references, Fall 2022 (PDF)
- Rustici Software: How relevant is SCORM? SCORM Cloud data, February 2026
- scorm.com: SCORM versions and AICC HACP
- 1EdTech: Learning Tools Interoperability (LTI)
- H5P.org
- H5P.org: H5P and xAPI
- iSpring Free: output formats listed, including cmi5
Keep reading
Last reviewed 21 November 2026. Recourse publishes these guides for learning, customer education and change teams. Details drawn from public sources can change.