eLearning standards and platforms

SCORM 1.2 vs SCORM 2004: what is different, and which should you use?

When you publish a course for an LMS, the export screen asks you to pick a SCORM version. Here is what the choice actually changes.

Updated

eLearning standards and platforms
Short answerChoose SCORM 1.2 unless you have a specific reason not to. It runs in nearly every LMS. Choose SCORM 2004 (3rd or 4th edition) when you need separate "completed" and "passed" results, or your course is long enough to hit 1.2's limit on saved progress.

Which is newer?

SCORM 2004 is the newer one. Despite the names, there is no "SCORM 2.0" in between.

VersionReleased
SCORM 1.2October 2001
SCORM 2004, 1st editionJanuary 2004
SCORM 2004, 2nd editionJuly 2004
SCORM 2004, 3rd editionOctober 2006
SCORM 2004, 4th editionMarch 2009

The 3rd edition is the most widely used of the 2004 family. Nothing has been released since 2009. See Rustici Software's history of the versions for more.

The differences that matter

SCORM 1.2SCORM 2004
StatusOne field. A course is "completed" or "passed" or "failed".Two fields. Completion and success are recorded separately.
Saved progressUp to 4,096 charactersUp to 64,000 characters (3rd and 4th editions)
Ordering of lessonsLeft to the courseSequencing rules the LMS can enforce
Question dataThe course can send answers but not read them backCan send and read back, with the question text
ScoreA raw numberA raw number and a scaled one
LMS supportNearly universalCommon, but varies by LMS and edition

1. One status or two

In SCORM 1.2 a course has a single status. It cannot say "finished, and failed" as two separate facts: the last value written wins. So a learner who reaches the end but fails the quiz shows up as either "completed" or "failed", depending on how the course was built.

SCORM 2004 keeps two records: completion (did they get to the end) and success (did they pass). If your reports need both, this is the main reason to choose 2004.

2. How much progress can be saved

When a learner leaves a course half way, the course saves a note of where they were so it can resume. SCORM 1.2 allows 4,096 characters for that note. A long course with many pages, quizzes and variables can run out, and the symptom is a course that forgets where the learner was. SCORM 2004 3rd and 4th editions allow 64,000 characters.

3. Sequencing

SCORM 2004 lets the package tell the LMS rules such as "module 2 unlocks after module 1 is passed". It is powerful, hard to get right, and LMSs differ in how well they handle it. Most modern authoring tools control the order inside the course and do not use it.

4. Under the hood

The two versions use different names for the same things, so a 1.2 course will not run as 2004 or the other way round. The LMS reads the version from the manifest and loads the matching player. You pick the version when you export. You cannot change it by renaming anything.

LMS support

Almost every LMS plays SCORM 1.2. Most commercial ones also play SCORM 2004, though some support only certain editions or handle sequencing poorly. Moodle, one of the most widely used, fully supports SCORM 1.2 but not SCORM 2004.

This is why SCORM 1.2 is the default for anyone who sells or shares courses: you often do not know which LMS the course will end up in.

Which should you choose?

Your situationChoose
The course will go to customers or several LMSsSCORM 1.2
You do not know what the LMS supportsSCORM 1.2
You use MoodleSCORM 1.2
Reports must show "completed" and "passed" separatelySCORM 2004, 3rd or 4th edition
A long course keeps losing learners' placeSCORM 2004, 3rd or 4th edition
You need rich data from outside the LMSNeither. Look at xAPI or cmi5.

How to tell which version a SCORM file is

  1. Open it in a viewer. Drop the .zip into our free SCORM viewer. It shows the version, and plays both 1.2 and 2004.
  2. Or look in the manifest. Unzip the package, open imsmanifest.xml in a text editor and find the line that starts <schemaversion>. It will say 1.2, or name a 2004 edition.

Can you convert SCORM 1.2 to 2004?

Not by editing the zip. The reliable way is to go back to the tool the course was made in and export again with the other version selected. If you no longer have the source, see can you edit a SCORM file? for what is possible.

If you are starting from a PDF, a video or a web page, our free SCORM converter lets you choose 1.2 or 2004 when it builds the package.

What Recourse exports

Recourse exports SCORM 1.2, for the compatibility reason above. Its packages report completion and a score, including the score from a hands-on simulation. SCORM export is on the Pro plan. See pricing.

Key takeaways

  • SCORM 2004 is newer. SCORM 1.2 is more widely supported.
  • 2004 records completion and pass or fail separately, and saves far more progress data.
  • Default to 1.2. Move to 2004 3rd or 4th edition only for a reason you can name.
  • To switch versions, export again from the original tool.

Questions people ask

Which is newer, SCORM 1.2 or SCORM 2004?
SCORM 2004 is newer. SCORM 1.2 was released in October 2001. SCORM 2004 came out in January 2004 and was revised through four editions, the last in March 2009.
What is the main difference between SCORM 1.2 and SCORM 2004?
SCORM 1.2 records a single status for a course, while SCORM 2004 records completion and success separately. SCORM 2004 also allows much more saved progress data and adds sequencing rules. SCORM 1.2 is supported by more LMSs.
Should I use SCORM 1.2 or SCORM 2004?
Use SCORM 1.2 by default, because nearly every LMS supports it. Use SCORM 2004 3rd or 4th edition if you need separate completed and passed results, or if a long course is running out of space to save progress.
Does Moodle support SCORM 2004?
Moodle fully supports SCORM 1.2. Its own documentation says SCORM 2004 is not fully supported, so SCORM 1.2 is the safe choice for Moodle.
How do I know which SCORM version a file is?
Open the package in a SCORM viewer, which will show the version, or unzip it and look for the schemaversion line in the imsmanifest.xml file.
Can I convert a SCORM 1.2 package to SCORM 2004?
Not reliably by editing the package. The dependable way is to export the course again from the authoring tool it was built in, choosing the other version.

Keep reading

Last reviewed 19 November 2026. Recourse publishes these guides for learning, customer education and change teams. Details drawn from public sources can change.